I did get a reply to my current e-mail address, but it essentially gave me a link to the same password recovery page that starts the endless loop. It was just a stock prewritten answer for evryone looking for their password. I got exactly the same response on a ticket for a different avi of mine.
At least the response was within 24 hours though. sheesh. ( I had just sent the ticket in when I wrote my post above)
I can't change my e-mail for these accounts without my password, and I can't recieve an e-mail with my password because they send it to my old, cancelled, address.