Okay I think I need to clarify something before this gets out of hand....
I'm not going to AR anything FOR anyone to LL. That's not my purpose. What I'm trying to find out is how much a visitor of my sim is allowed to report to ME, as simowner. And how much of the TOS then applies to my simrules.
Example: three people are having a conversation on my sim. They are regulars and never bother anyone. Then a new visitor comes along, gets in the middle of their conversation and begins to act like a complete juvenile. Over the next several days this person is reported to me as being a complete nuisance for doing similar things to other visitors.
Now of course I'll ban this person without thinking hard about it, because it would be silly to warn every visitor of such a person and to ask them to block and blacklist him/her. But all I have to go on is the word of the harassed visitors. I don't have actual proof that it took place, and the guilty person probably won't freely give up their chatlog. Now I won't lose any sleep over banning such a person without actual proof, and I hightly doubt that person would report me to LL.
So what I was trying to find out if I, in any way, could defend the banning without requesting chatlogs from all involved? Could the person who was banned ever turn around and report me for wrongful banning or whatever?
You say I'm in no position to find out what has happened. I disagree with that statement. As simowner I have every right to defend my visitors, or try to referee in a situation if it means I don't have to ban anyone. The less people I ban, the more people visit my sim. I have no wish to become a permanent moderator on my sim. I've made it expressly clear that if there are problems that I'm to be contacted, and I fully intend to back that up, but in doing so I want to stay within LL policies and merge them, where possible, with my simrules.
Now if you, or anyone else here, know for a fact that I can ban people to my heart's content, then so be it. End of question. I'm just trying to find out if it won't come back to me and legally bite me in the ass.