[I created an alternative account a long time ago]

I created an account multiple years ago, back in 2009 or around there under the name "Montgomery Edenbaum" and I am trying to get access to it. I do not remember the password and the e-mail associated with it no longer exists. I selected the "e-mail inactive" button but it just brings me back to the same page to send the information to the e-mail again.
Is there another way I can recover this account?